Personal data protection, case II SA/Wa 1212/10

February 4th, 2011, Tomasz Rychlicki

The case of Tomasz W. and his image treated as personal data still continues. See “Personal data protection, case I OSK 667/09“. GIODO annulled its earlier decision, however it also refused to take account Tomasz W. requests in its new decision. GIODO ruled that personal data (photos and captions) of Tomasz W. are not presented on the website, and are not publicly available because they were removed from the specified address. GIODO also noted that Nasza-Klasa is still processing the personal data treating it as evidence, because it keeps them on its servers and in the system’s memory. GIODO finally held that the Company, as controller, is processing these data under provisions of Article 23(1)(v) of the PPD, under which such the processing of data is permitted because it is necessary for the purpose of the legitimate interests pursued by the controller and that the processing does not violate the rights and freedoms of the data subject. Among the reasons justifying the data processing, GIODO mentioned the possibility of establishing the responsibility of the recipient for violations of the Terms of Service that were set by the Company. This judgment is not final yet. GIODO filed a cassation complaint.

The Voivodeship Administrative Court in Warsaw in its judgment of 1 December 2010 case file II SA/Wa 1212/10 ruled that, these circumstances do not fulfill the conditions for legitimate interests of data processing. It should be noted that the condition relates to the existing and unquestionable situation, so if there is a need to demonstrate a need to claim in business, not a situation where the data are processed for eventual trial and the possible need to prove that personal data obtained without the consent of the person concerned shall be processed in accordance with the law. The Court also noted that Tomasz W. only announced but he did not initiate any courts proceedings against Nasza-Klasa. Therefore, according to the Court, Nasza-Klasa was not allowed to process personal data only to protect itself against any future and uncertain claims mentioned by Tomasz W. Otherwise, there are doubts how long to process personal data if Tomasz W. fails to comply with his announcement.

See also “Polish regulations on personal data protection” and “Polish case law on personal data protection“.